Do Higher Taxes Equal Greater Happiness?

While sitting in my backyard on an early Saturday morning reading the news, I came across another one of those silly happiest countries on earth reports. I find them silly anyway. Trying to determine an entire country’s happiness and then ranking them against one another seems to be a waste of time at first glance. But the silliness and the thought of hundreds, maybe thousands of hours spent making this report piqued my interest, and so I decided to dig deeper into this list of so-called happy countries and see how exactly this is determined…and why a specific region seems to have a monopoly as the top ranked. A region with obscenely high taxes. Could it be that higher taxes equal greater happiness?

Much of what I read and listen to in the FIRE-sphere has to do with happiness. I can see why. There are only two reasons why one would choose to go down the not-so-easy FIRE path; you are either currently unhappy and being financially independent will somehow make you happy. Or, you are happy, but being financially independent will make you happier.

Either way, happiness is the goal of FIRE. There might be a thing or two to learn from why these countries are so happy and why paying more taxes to their government may play a role in this.

world happiness report

Surprise, the Scandinavian countries top the world happiness list. Those countries tucked just under the arctic circle continually rank highest on this list. How is that? Isn’t it dreary and cold most of the year in those parts with winters terribly long and arduous? Aren’t the taxes some of the highest in the world in those countries? How could these two factors alone allow a place to rank year after year as one of the happiest countries/regions on the entire planet?

The UN is the responsible party for publishing this yearly report called the World Happiness Report. It’s based on a Gallup World Poll survey of 1,000 people from each country. It’s based on real GDP per capita, social support, life expectancy, the perception of an individual’s freedom, corruption, and neighbors.

Here’s the top 10. You can read the most recent report here. It’s interesting and academically in depth.

2020 Rankings. The United States is 14th in 2020.
These are the ranking based on a 3-year average(the US is 19th here). But you can see how the ranking was measured, if you go to the site the chart is interactive. What is dystopia you ask? Well, it’s an imaginary country with the least happy people, the “benchmark” to measure from.

The UN and the academics who put this together use a series of factors for its rankings. Seems most of the factors have to do with money. From asking people how likely they think their wallet will be returned by a neighbor, to using mathematical formulas to calculate a country’s income inequality. It turns out that a country’s income inequality plays a huge role in a society’s happiness. Being a personal finance nerd, this wealth equality factor caught my eye.

Equality. Such a powerful yet contentious word. In the US, from solely a financial perspective, wealth equality can ring antithetical to the whole capitalist American thing. For most of the twentieth century, the United States was engaged in a bitter and expensive Cold War against the ideology of state-sponsored “wealth equality” aka communism. We all know who won that war of ideology, and for good reason. One cannot escape the power and allure of the free market and private capital, not even the Soviets.

Yet, for the US being one of the richest countries in the world, its high wealth and power propelled by capitalistic income inequality, why does the US rank 14th on the list of happy countries? We’ve actually never ranked in the top ten since the creation of this list.

The United States has better weather (well, I do here in California) and lower taxes than the top ten on that list. Our passport is one of the most powerful in the world. I would think that would be a cocktail for happiness…at least top ten happiness, right?

higher taxes = greater happiness?

Look at how much these happy residents of Scandinavia pay in taxes! Really makes me wonder if paying higher taxes equals greater happiness.

Top Personal Income Tax Rates in Europe | Tax Foundation
via taxfoundation.org. Denmark is #1 here at 55.9%!! But they do have free university,free healthcare, high minimum wage, and free childcare…is that happiness? What about the cold snowy winters?

How can these Nordic countries be the happiest places to live when half your money is taxed away? You’d give up nearly half your income in the top 8 happiest countries in the world. I mean, here in the United States, the richest only pay 37% in income federally, and you’d have to take home more than $622K (married filing jointly) annually to pay that, even our progressive tax tier means that only a portion is taxed that high.

And look at those capital gains taxes in Europe and especially Scandinavia. In the United States we pay a long term capital gains rate of 15% for an income of $80K-$496K.

2020 Capital Gains Tax Rates in Europe | Tax Foundation
via taxfoundation.org. Look at Turkey! 0%!!

There’s one list the US does seem to continually top. And that’s wealth per adult. Credit Suisse published this list of the top per capita wealth by countries in the world. The United States is number 2.

via Credit Suisse global wealth report 2020.

Americans have the most money in the world and pay fewer taxes on it. Keeping your money for yourself should make you happy? Maybe its not about having more money.

In fact, if you want to disregard the UN Happiness Report, you can’t believe that Americans consume the vast majority of the world’s pharmaceuticals because we are secretly the happiest country. Could it be that having and making more money might lead to more stress? More uncontentedness?

Is it less stressful to know that your health coverage isn’t dependent on your employer? I would imagine. Most of these top-ranked countries have free tuition for universities. Free childcare. And very high minimum wages. The Scandinavians also feel inclined to work less (maybe because they know they’ll pay more taxes on more income?) with the Danish work week consisting of 37 hours and capped by law at 48 hours per week. In Sweden, the average workweek is 35 hours according to Statistica. The Swedes have even provided tax breaks for repairing things like appliances, cars, and bikes, instead of throwing away and buying new…talk about a FIRE like mentality.

The Norwegians and Swedes have a word for this urge not to want and compete for more and more and it’s called logom. The Finnish use sopivasti. Which translates to moderation or just enough. Culturally, it’s the avoidance of extremes and risk. Maybe it’s this common lack of want that drives happiness levels up. This mindset of contentment with things as they are. If there’s no urge for newer and better things, this has to have an effect on the people living in a society like this. It’s the frugal mindset applied to every aspect of life.

wealth equality and happiness

The Gini Index is used by the World Happiness Report to help determine rankings. Guess what? This index also happens to correlate with the “happiest countries” list. Coincidence? Maybe. But maybe, it backs up the equality is happiness theme a bit more. I mean it’s math. Hard to argue against numbers.

The way this income equality formula is determined stems from an Italian statistician named Corrado Gini. He ended up being a bad guy (a fascist) in the second world war, but his coefficient is still widely used today.

Gini came up with a method for analyzing the distribution of wealth in a country. Where 0% on the list formulates to pure equality and 100% is the most unequal.

via wikipedia. Based on World Bank data ranging from 1992-2018

The “happiest countries” have the least amount of income inequality, as you can see above. I have to imagine that knowing you make close to the same amount as your neighbor and the waitress at the restaurant you’re patronizing, or the news reporter on tv, has to take some edge off the rat race razor blade. Not seeing too many people suffering on the streets certainly would be nice too, I know, as I walk the streets of San Francisco daily.

But it’s more than just equal income levels and the shared payment of high taxes that make these egalitarian countries stand out. There’s a cultural aspect of frowning on individuality and exceptionalism. It’s generally looked down upon to brag or boast in the Nordic countries. Something that runs very counter to the American culture I’m used to. I find it fascinating to wonder if this Law of Jante may play into Scandinavia’s general happiness and quality of life rankings…this humbleness that pervades their society.

Jantelagen or The Law of Jante is from a novel written by the Danish born Aksel Sandemose. Jante is a fictional town in the novel A Fugitive Crosses His Tracks. You can read the laws here on Wikipedia. And here’s a better explanation on it from Georgetown University. And another by the BBC. Plenty of writing on this subject. The rules can give an insight into the culture of the region.

The ten rules state:

  1. You’re not to think you are anything special.
  2. You’re not to think you are as good as we are.
  3. You’re not to think you are smarter than we are.
  4. You’re not to imagine yourself better than we are.
  5. You’re not to think you know more than we do.
  6. You’re not to think you are more important than we are.
  7. You’re not to think you are good at anything.
  8. You’re not to laugh at us.
  9. You’re not to think anyone cares about you.
  10. You’re not to think you can teach us anything.

And let’s be honest, in the FIRE community there’s a little bit of Jantelagen to go around. This could easily apply to how the FIRE pursuers see the outside consumer world…or maybe a FIRE blogger offering a paid course on personal finance. We, with our high savings rates and frugal values (admittedly or not), silently judge those who are making obscenely bad choices when it comes to money. We scoff at consumerism and those people borrowing money for BMW’s and putting Gucci glasses on their credit cards. I can think of a few of the jantelogen rules that might accurately describe someone who’s using money…or even worse, borrowed money, to brag and show off his or her “status”.

rose colored glasses

Okay, let me take off my rose colored glasses now. Nobody, not even the UN, can just broadly make blanket statements about a country and how happy the people who live there are. If there’s one thing that grinds my gears, it’s broad statements about a country, any country. People are too varied and their lives too nuanced to say if you were living in one of these top ranking countries you would be happier. Or that someone living in an unhappy country must be a miserable grump.

They only surveyed 1,000 of us Americans out of a population of 328 million. Might have been a few sour apples in that bunch. And I must admit that my trust in poll accuracy will likely be forever marred by distrust after a few catastrophic polling errors in recent years.

At work sometimes they encourage us to fill out those “Best Places to Work” surveys. Luckily, I do work at a great company, but I can see where things can get off the rails on these surveys. People want to be happy and want to show others their happiness, so they may have the urge to fudge a bit on their answers. What does hold some water for me is the correlation of happy nations to greater wealth equality via the Gini Index.

Another last thing that America probably owns that these Scandinavian golden children of the World Happiness Report don’t, is that it’s probably a hell of a lot easier to hit financial independence in the US than those high tax “happier” countries. We have the ability to keep more of our income to invest. And let’s not forget the fewer capital gains taxes we will pay when it comes time to withdraw our money.

Personally, I’d be willing to pay more taxes for universal health coverage. But man, it would take some time to wrap my head around a 50% tax on my income to pay for it, but if high taxation is the ticket to happiness…that’s a tough pill for an American to accept.

As Americans, we do pay this high tax or cost eventually, maybe not directly to the government, but we pay it. It comes out of our own pocket for health coverage, childcare, and college tuition. At a minimum, we have the advantage of choice, though there’s certainly some stress that might accompany that freedom of choice. Especially for those who don’t have the ability or capacity to make good choices.

So do higher taxes really equal greater happiness?

Maybe it’s not the higher taxes that make these countries so “happy”, but the wealth equality? Scandinavians have less choice on how their money is spent by the government, but sometimes too much choice can leave you feeling dissatisfied and disappointed.

There are more than a few similarities between the Scandinavian cultural use of lagom in those “happy” countries and the undeniable aspects of stoic and eastern philosophy that come with living a frugal life. To FIRE, in the traditional 4% sense, is to be okay with not having everything, and challenging the human desire to want, which in my opinion is key to being happy and content.

Maybe the UN ought to include a few FIRE members in next year’s World Happiness Report survey…that may be the ticket to get the US into the top ten for once, I’m just saying.

What do you think? Does higher taxation equal greater happiness…obviously, this means a bigger government. Is the World Happiness Report just a bunch of BS? Has anybody been to Scandinavia, would love to hear about your experiences? I’ve never been but now I’m itching to see this pricy utopia/dystopia.


Discover more from Happily Disengaged

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

23 Comments

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.